THE MIDDLE MARK
What to Check When a Client’s Renewal Price Goes Up
Clear updates. Confident conversations. Better prepared agents.
Your clients are opening renewal letters and comparing prices. Help them see what each choice means for their doctors, medicines, and budget. This week, we look at the calls coming in and what you can check before you answer.
AT YOUR DESK THIS WEEK
What to bring to the next call
- ACA renewal calls ↓Have the renewal notice and a local plan quote ready.
- Medicare drug reviews ↓Ask what the client takes and which pharmacy they use.
- Employer renewals ↓Start with the current group quote and the owner’s budget.
01 · ACA open enrollment
“Why did my price go up if plans still cost $50?”
For agents helping Marketplace clients renew for 2027
HealthCare.gov open enrollment runs from November 1, 2026, through January 15, 2027. A client may hear that low-cost plans are still available, then open a renewal letter with a higher price. Here’s how to explain both numbers. CMS says more than 75% of people who buy coverage through HealthCare.gov will have access to a plan for $50 a month or less in 2027. That means at least one option after tax credits. Their current plan may cost more.
KFF found that the average price of the benchmark plan rose 13% nationwide before tax credits. The benchmark is the second-lowest-cost Silver plan in an area. It helps set the tax credit. A client’s own price also depends on the plan they pick, where they live, their household and their expected income.
Try this on a renewal call. Say a client sees two quotes after tax credits, one at $45 and one at $80. Those are sample prices. The first saves $420 a year in premiums. Before switching, check the deductible, whether the specialist is in the plan’s network, and what the client’s usual drugs will cost. If the client qualifies for extra savings on out-of-pocket costs, show the Silver option that gives them those savings.
Put this year’s bill, the 2027 renewal and one 2027 alternative side by side. Show the full price and the price after the tax credit for each 2027 choice.
Sources CMS • 2027 Marketplace plans and prices · KFF • Nine things to watch during 2027 open enrollment · HealthCare.gov • Extra savings with a Silver plan
02 · Medicare annual enrollment
“If I keep my drug plan, what will I pay next year?”
For agents reviewing stand-alone Medicare Part D plans
A client can keep the same drug plan and still get a different bill in January. On October 30, KFF reported that 10.4 million of the 13.6 million people in stand-alone Part D plans who do not get Extra Help would pay a higher monthly premium in 2027 if they stay in their current plan. That’s 76% of this group. Extra Help is Medicare’s program that helps people with limited income and resources pay for drugs.
Look beyond the premium. Imagine a client finds a plan that costs $8 less per month. Their usual medicine would cost $14 more each month at their pharmacy. With 12 fills and all other costs equal, they would spend $72 more over the year. A smaller monthly bill can hide a bigger cost at the counter.
During a scheduled review, enter each drug, dose, refill amount and pharmacy into Medicare Plan Compare. Check the yearly estimate and whether the client needs approval for any medicine. If a cheaper pharmacy is across town, ask whether the client can actually get there.
During Medicare annual enrollment, which ends December 7, give the client the estimated yearly cost for each plan you review and the pharmacy used for the estimate.
Sources KFF • Medicare Part D premiums and cost sharing in 2027 · Medicare • Compare health and drug plans · Medicare • Open enrollment dates
03 · Federal Marketplace compliance • November 4 update
Can a new hire handle a federal Marketplace enrollment yet?
For agency owners and agents using HealthCare.gov
Before assigning a renewal, check the agent’s federal Marketplace registration. A federal rule took effect September 22. In general, agents and brokers who had no federal Marketplace agreement for plan year 2026 must wait to finish 2027 registration. This can affect an experienced agent who sold coverage elsewhere. An agent who signed a 2026 agreement can still complete the required 2027 training and registration.
The pause applies where states use the federal enrollment platform. A state that runs its own enrollment platform sets its own process. The federal rule runs until February 1, 2027, unless it changes sooner.
Where the court cases stand. Two agent groups challenged the pause. On October 29, the federal government asked the judge to keep it in place while the Health Agents for America case moves forward. A federal judge scheduled a hearing for November 5 in the related cases brought by Health Agents for America and the National Association of Benefits and Insurance Professionals. As of this edition’s November 4 cutoff, the hearing was still ahead. A scheduled hearing gives an agency no authority to put a new producer on a federal enrollment today.
Look up the agent’s own National Producer Number on the CMS registration completion list before assigning a case. Check the state license and any carrier appointment separately.
Sources Federal Register • Temporary pause on new federal Marketplace agent registrations · U.S. District Court • October 21 scheduling order for both cases · CMS • Agent and broker registration, training and completion lists · U.S. District Court filing • Federal government’s October 29 response
04 · Florida property and casualty
A Florida driver asks about the $46 million Infinity refund
For agents serving current or former Florida auto clients
On November 2, Florida announced that Infinity Auto Insurance Company must return more than $46 million in excess profits from 2023 through 2025. That number is the total for eligible drivers. Under state law, each driver’s share depends on the premium tied to their policy in the final year.
Start with the old policy. If a caller says, “I switched companies. Should I watch the mail?” ask who insured their car on December 31, 2025. Florida law ties the refund to people on record that day with a voluntary private passenger auto policy. Look at the first page of the policy for the exact company name. Help the client find the insurer’s official phone number and confirm their address.
The October 22 order gives Infinity 60 days to provide refunds or renewal credits. Ask the insurer which applies. Infinity must try to find policyholders whose checks come back. If it still cannot reach them, Florida’s unclaimed property process applies.
Set the right expectation on the call. The order concerns past premiums. Use the client’s renewal notice to answer a separate question about their next rate.
Sources Florida Office of Insurance Regulation • November 2 refund announcement · Florida Office of Insurance Regulation • October 22 final order · Florida Legislature • Who qualifies under section 627.066(8)
05 · Large-group benefits
What can a large employer ask about the cost of its drug plan?
For agents advising large employers that pay their own health claims
A benefits manager may ask, “We pay a fee for our drug plan. Is that all the drug manager earns?” A pharmacy benefit manager, or PBM, runs the drug benefit for a health plan. Its pay can come from several places. For example, it may keep part of a drugmaker’s rebate or charge the plan more for a prescription than it pays the pharmacy.
On November 2, the U.S. Department of Labor published a final rule that requires more detail about these payments. It covers PBM services for large, self-insured employer health plans subject to the federal benefits law known as ERISA. In a self-insured plan, the employer pays claims. The rule also covers certain brokers and consultants affiliated with the PBM.
Use the employer’s plan year. The rule takes effect January 4, 2027. Its requirements apply to plan years that start on or after July 1, 2027. For a covered employer whose plan year starts each January 1, the first one starts January 1, 2028.
When the employer reviews its next PBM contract, ask for a sample report. Have the vendor show which fees the plan pays, how much rebate money comes back and who can check the figures.
Sources Federal Register • Final rule on pharmacy benefit manager fee disclosures · U.S. Department of Labor • Final rule fact sheet
FROM NHP UNIVERSITY
In your agency this month
06 · GROUP BENEFITS • AGENT PRACTICE
Bring two ZIP codes to your next group renewal
For agents meeting with small employers
If a business owner calls about a group renewal, ask, “What do your employees want to keep about their coverage?” Then use two ZIP codes where employees live. Look up individual plans in each area. A nearby doctor may be in one plan’s network and out of another’s.
CHOICE Arrangements were previously known as individual coverage HRAs, or ICHRAs. The employer sets how much it will contribute. Eligible employees choose their own individual coverage and can be reimbursed for qualifying premiums. Compare what workers would pay with what they pay today. The offer can change their eligibility for Marketplace tax credits.
uPPo Benefits offers agents a dedicated contact, help getting employers started, and materials to explain the benefit. Check the start date together. Current employees generally need written notice 90 days before the plan year begins.
Bring the group renewal, the employer’s budget, and sample local plan prices. Use those numbers to decide with the owner whether to explore CHOICE Arrangements.
Sources CMS and SBA on CHOICE Arrangements · HealthCare.gov employer guide and notice rules · uPPo Benefits agent support
07 · FROM NHP UNIVERSITY • COURSE SPOTLIGHT
Practice the question your next employer will ask
For agents building group benefits skills
Picture an owner asking, “If I set aside the same budget next year, how much will my workers have to pay?” Practice answering that question before your next group meeting.
Start with NHP University’s four-hour foundations course for a closer look at plan design, rules, and enrollment. If you need continuing education credit, check the catalog for your state.
For practice talking with an owner, the uPPo certification course walks you through the employee list, which groups of workers the offer covers, and what workers can afford. Try the decision exercise in English or Spanish. Completing it earns NHP University’s private uPPo course certificate.
Choose a course for the skill you want to practice. After the lesson, rehearse one employer question with a teammate.
Sources NHPU foundations course and duration · NHPU course catalog by state · uPPo course outline in English · Programa del curso en español
08 · AGENCY MARKETING • OPENCHARTS
Make one enrollment reminder work in two places
For agents creating client education and social posts
How many tools did you pay for the last time you made a post and a video? Try one small project before you buy another subscription.
OpenCharts is a TheoVex workspace. Give Theo, its AI assistant, your agency’s approved appointment checklist, logo, and colors. Use the checklist to make a social graphic, then turn the same advice into a short video. Director Mode lets you change a scene and compare takes. Have a teammate check the wording before you share either piece.
Compare the cost of the tools you could drop with the OpenCharts plan and video credits you’d use.
Want to practice? Bring one question clients ask you this week and take NHP University’s free, nine-module OpenCharts Director Mode – AI Video course.
Start your practice video with one useful sentence, such as “Bring your medicine list and the name of your usual pharmacy to our appointment.”
Sources TheoVex on the OpenCharts agency workspace · OpenCharts marketing tools · Director Mode video guide · OpenCharts plans and credits · NHPU Director Mode course
Prepared November 4, 2026. Back to the top ↑

